Be Cautious Altering Tables Using SQL Server Management Studio SSMS
Often times we use the SQL Server Management Studio GUI to perform simple tasks such as altering a column in a table. However, you should always check your scripts before blindly performing the actions recommended by SSMS, because they may not always be, and are often not, the best way to perform actions within SQL Server.
Let's take a look at a simple task of resizing a column in the AdventureWorks database. If you need to change the NationalIDNumber in the HumanResources.Employee table, you can simply run the following script.
ALTER TABLE HumanResources.Employee
ALTER COLUMN NationalIDNumber NVARCHAR(20) NOT NULL
Now, let's perform the same task using SSMS. You can right-click the HumanResources.Employee table and select Design from the context menu to display the Table Designer. If you change the column length and generate the change script, you will end up with a script that contains 443 lines of code and involves creating a temp table with the new definition, inserting all the data from the old table, dropping the old table, and then renaming the temp table. If this operation is performed on a large table, what would have been a quick change can now take several hours.
SQL Server 2008 Management Studio has an option on by default that prevents operations that are required drop and create tables; however, this option can be, and often is, turned off. Sometimes the best way to perform certian operations is by creating and populating a new table, you just need to be aware of what is about to happen and make sure you are okay with it first.
- Check out some Best practices for SQL Server database ALTER table operations
- Read the tip Error 'Saving changes is not permitted.' in SQL Server 2008 Management Studio to find out how to change the configuration option that will allow you to make changes that require you to drop and recreate tables.
- Review the complete ALTER TABLE syntax in Books Online
Last Updated: 2010-06-03
About the author
View all my tips